Blog
Hail dents on a Melbourne Colorbond roof are impact marks. They are not automatically leaks. Photograph each pitch from the ground before anyone restores, repaints or lodges a claim. A dented sheet can still be weather-tight; a leak usually sits at a lap, screw or penetration. Roof Revival Melbourne maps the difference on an inspection.
Tile bruises are a different surface and a different article. This one is steel sheet: the dimples you can sometimes see from the yard after a cell, the question of whether water is actually entering, and the order of operations if you might claim or if someone has offered to “restore” the dents away. The money page is Hail Damage Roof Repairs Melbourne. We document what the ice did. We do not write chalk, fade or a dirty roof as hail.
Colorbond is a coated steel sheet formed into a profile. Hail hits the face and can leave a dimple on the broad pan or a sharper bruise on a rib. That mark is impact. It tells you a cell passed over the house. It does not, on its own, tell you the house is leaking. A lot of dented sheet still sheds water the way it did the day before the storm. The coating may be bruised. The shape may annoy you every time you look up from the clothesline. The ceiling can still be dry.
A leak is water passing a joint: a lap, a screw line, a ridge, a flue boot, a skylight, a solar bracket, a valley. Ice can open those details, or it can only dent the pans. Roof Revival Melbourne writes “dented, weather-tight” and “dented, and the west lap is open” as different findings. One sentence that merges them is how a bruise becomes a full replacement quote.
You can start that split from the ground. After the roof is dry, look from the yard. Do you see dimples catching the light on one pitch? Is any sheet lifted, split, or missing? Is there a new ceiling stain, and did it appear on the night of the cell or has it been there since last winter? A new stain plus a storm date belongs in the notes. An old stain does not become hail because a cell visited the suburb. Stay off the wet roof while you look. Metal that has just taken hail is still a wet roof, and a dented pan is not a foothold.
Young metal roofs across Point Cook, Tarneit and Craigieburn fail at details more often than they fail in the middle of a sheet. Hail does not change that habit. It adds impact to the same list. A screw that was already loose can be the point that starts dripping after the sheet flexes. A lap that was short, or laid with the weather running under it, can take a bruise and then a leak on the next westerly. A penetration boot that was already cracked can be the path, with dents everywhere else as scenery.
Faded paint, perished washers and dirt left after the storm are not hail. If the west pitch is dimpled and the south pitch is only faded, we say so. A clean face does not repair a lap, and this page is not a wash.
Split sheet is the impact finding that does matter. A pan creased hard enough to crack the steel, a rib folded, a sheet torn at a fixing, water staining on the underside that lines up with the storm night: those are leaks or leaks about to happen. They still do not automatically condemn every other sheet on the house. The map says how many, on which pitch, and whether the fixings and laps around them failed with them.
The order is photographs, then decisions. From the ground, in daylight: a wide shot of every pitch, the street front, any dents you can see without climbing, any lifted edge, and every ceiling stain with the date. Add a note of when the cell passed, in your own words. If a car, a skylight dome or a metal flue lid was marked and you can photograph those from the ground, they help an assessor see that ice fell at that address. They do not prove every roof dent is new, and we will not pretend they do.
Then stop, if a claim is even a possibility. Do not book a repaint, a “restore”, or a full sheet replacement that covers the marks before an assessor has seen them or you have a written scope. Coating a dented roof makes the impact harder to read. Swapping the sheets and sending the old ones to scrap does the same. Make-safe still comes first if the roof is actually open — that is a cover and a photo, not a new colour. How Victorian claims are lodged and why the evidence has to survive until the assessor visits is covered once, here: insurance roof claims in Victoria.
Roof Revival Melbourne adds the on-roof pack when the surface is safe: which bays are dimpled, which sheets are split, which laps and fixings are open, whether the ceiling stain lines up with a detail or with nothing. We use plain labels an assessor can read. We separate the storm night from wear that was already on the roof. You lodge the claim. We do not invent a write-off because the pans look uneven in a phone photo taken at dusk.
Living with dents is a legitimate outcome. If the sheet is intact, the fixings hold, the laps are tight and the ceiling stayed dry through the next rain, a dimpled roof can remain a dimpled roof. Some owners hate the look and want the face replaced on the street pitch only. That is a choice about appearance, and it should be priced as appearance, not dressed up as a structural emergency. Some owners want the whole field replaced because a neighbour was told to. The neighbour’s roof is not your scope.
Replacement of sheet is the outcome when the steel has split, when fixings have pulled, or when the damage is dense enough that chasing individual pans is nonsense. Matching profile and colour is part of that conversation. A one-sheet repair that flashes and laps correctly can be the entire job. A pitch of tired, heavily dented sheet on a house that was already due for a re-roof can be the start of a larger one. We will not know which from the footpath, which is why the ground photos book the inspection and the inspection writes the quote.
Photograph your own pitches. Cells are familiar in Box Hill and Doncaster, and they still land on metal roofs elsewhere.
A spray coat over hail dents is a finish on top of an unanswered question. If you were going to claim, the question is now harder. If you were going to find out whether a lap leaks, the coat did not answer it. Restoration, where it belongs, is a specified system on a roof that still has a life as a roof. It is not a way to blur impact marks before anyone has agreed what failed. Painting a sound metal roof after the hail question is settled is a different job, on the painting page, with a scope that says paint.
Silicone along a screw line, tar over a dent, or a chemical mix in a lap is not a repair and not a record. It hides the detail we need to see, it often traps water, and it fails on the next hot week or the next front. Leave the surface. If water is dripping tonight, catch it inside, photograph from the ground, and ask for make-safe. Stay off the roof.
A local repair is not automatically a $4,000–$12,000 restore or a $20,000+ replacement. Those figures are planning bands we use elsewhere for a full tile restoration system and for many re-roofs. A hail visit on Colorbond might be a report and no building work, because the dents are cosmetic and the details are sound. It might be a short list of fixings and one sheet. It might be a pitch. It might be a whole roof if the inspection shows the field has failed. The invoice follows that list. Industry chatter and a neighbour’s cash settlement are not the list.
Bring the ground photos, the date of the cell, and any ceiling stains. We map dents separately from leaks. Concrete and terracotta from the same cell belong on the tile hail article, not this one.
Send suburb, storeys, the date of the cell and ground photos of each pitch. Roof Revival Melbourne — 0426 516 883 · info@roofrevivalmelbourne.com.au
