What water does once the bed is dust
Rain driven at the hip enters under the cap and runs until it finds a way down. Sarking may catch it for years and then sag. Without sarking, the ceiling is the tray. The stain grows after westerlies and southerlies more than after straight-down rain, which is why people are sure the leak “moves”. It is moving along the ridge and dropping at a fastening or a sag. Fixing a single drip spot in the plaster, or sealing one crack from the top with a smear, leaves the rest of the dust bed in service.
The tiles immediately beside the ridge take blame they do not deserve. Starters crack because the cap and the bed are shifting on top of them. Swapping those tiles and leaving the bed is a repeat call. Include the joint. Leave the sound field alone.
Re-bedding is a reset, not a cosmetic edge
A re-bed lifts the caps, clears the failed mortar, and sets the caps back on a full new bed to the line of the roof. The edge is finished after the seat exists. Doing the edge first, or only the edge, is the failure mode this page is about. Length matters: every hip and the ridge, or only the cracked metres? A quote that says “ridges” without metres or a marked plan will be interpreted differently by everyone who reads it.
Flexible pointing and flexible ridge systems are a different specification. They are not a tube wiped over a crack, and they are not automatically superior to a proper cement bed. On a heritage clay roof the street may want a traditional finish. On a concrete hip with a history of rigid mortar cracking again, a flexible system may be the joint that suits the movement. Roof Revival Melbourne names which one, after the caps are known to be loose or sound. This page does not give a mortar mix. The mix is the trade. The scope is the decision to reset the seat.
When the field really is part of the same quote
Hard tiles and a dead ridge can still sit inside a restoration, because you are already on the roof and the face may be chalked. That is a choice to do the joint and the face together, not evidence the tiles failed. Soft tiles, rotten battens, or sarking that has fallen in along the whole hip can make it wasteful to re-bed a roof you are about to strip. Then the ridge failure is a finding inside a replacement, and the caps will be part of the new assembly rather than a rescue of the old one.
Salt and exposure change the timing, not the logic. Bayside hips can powder earlier. Eastern concrete hips powder on schedule with the chalking face. Inner terracotta hips powder and also need a cap that matches. The mechanism is the bed. The material changes the unit that goes back on it.
What to look at from the ground
From the street, look along the hip for missing pieces, dark cracks, and caps that seem to sag or twist. Look in the gutter for cement crumbs. Note whether the ceiling stain worsens after wind-driven rain. Stay off the ridge. A loose cap is a fall, and a walk along a powdered hip is how more caps come down.
Send the suburb, the storeys, and a photo along the ridge line. Roof Revival Melbourne will say whether the mortar has failed while the tiles remain sound, and whether the quote is a re-bed of the joint or a larger roof that happens to include one. The field being hard is allowed to stand. The open ridge is not asked to condemn it.